Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie
Brooklyn
Located along the Red Hook waterfront, Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is a legendary Brooklyn bakery dedicated to crafting pies made with fresh-squeezed lime juice. Creators heavily feature their iconic 'Swingle'—a frozen mini key lime pie on a stick dipped in rich dark Belgian chocolate, with variations like raspberry. Visitors love grabbing these signature frozen treats to enjoy outdoors near the scenic waterfront.
Commenters offer an overwhelmingly positive response, praising the pie shop as a top-tier, non-touristy local gem that triggers major cravings. While sentiment is glowing, some users raise practical critiques, such as spotty cellular reception around the Red Hook area. A few commenters also engage in friendly debates over the authenticity of the pie's specific toppings.
- Order the signature 'Swingle'—a frozen key lime tartlet dipped in Belgian dark chocolate (try the raspberry flavor).
- Enjoy your treat outside with scenic views near the Red Hook waterfront.
- Be aware that cellular reception can be weak in the local area.
- Appreciate authentic pies crafted with 100% fresh-squeezed key lime juice.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos