Lucky Charlie
Brooklyn
Lucky Charlie is a highly acclaimed Bushwick pizzeria featuring an authentic, historic coal-fired oven dating back to 1890 that extends beneath the sidewalk. Reviewers consistently praise its thin, ultra-crisp pies with smoky depth, highlighting the white pizza with 'nduja sausage, house-made cannelloni, and mountain-sized Caesar salad. The spot boasts immaculate vibes and late-night appeal, earning widespread acclaim as one of the best pizzerias in NYC.
Viewer feedback is notably polarized, contrasting creator enthusiasm with reviews that range from mediocre to impressed. Commenters raise questions regarding potential asbestos and hygiene issues linked to the historic oven's sub-sidewalk location, alongside serious allegations of staff mistreatment. While many express excitement to visit, others remain skeptical about the hype and authenticity.
- Order the white pizza with 'nduja sausage for a standout smoky, crispy slice.
- Pair your meal with the mountain-sized Caesar salad and house-made cannelloni.
- Prepare for long lines, with peak wait times often stretching up to 2.5 hours.
- Visit during late-night or off-peak hours to avoid the worst of the crowds.
- Expect a focused, traditional menu limited to just a few carefully crafted pie styles.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos