Roll N Roaster

Operating in Sheepshead Bay since 1970, Roll-N-Roaster is a beloved fast-casual staple known for gravy-dipped roast beef sandwiches served on seeded buns with optional Cheez Whiz. Visitors love the highly rated cheese fries alongside the lively, nostalgic atmosphere that features fun traditions like birthday wheel spins.

Commenters often spark debate over the rivalry between Roll-N-Roaster and fellow Brooklyn icon Brennan & Carr. While some give the edge to Brennan & Carr for sandwich execution, patrons consistently appreciate Roll-N-Roaster's varied menu and laid-back, fast-casual vibe.