Knapp Street Pizza

Knapp Street Pizza in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, is famous for its over-the-top, creative Italian-American mashups. They are especially known for their massive house-made garlic knot sandwiches stuffed with crispy fried chicken cutlets, melted mozzarella, and sauces like signature vodka sauce or rich meat Bolognese.

Commenters are largely enthusiastic about the massive, indulgent garlic knot sandwiches, with many calling them a crave-worthy favorite worth traveling for. However, some raise concerns regarding high prices, heavy calorie counts, and the potential for the oversized items to be dry, undercooked, or reheated compared to their social media hype.