Extraordinary Banana Pudding
La Mesa
Extraordinary Banana Pudding is a family-owned dessert shop in La Mesa specializing in rich, creamy puddings crafted from cherished family recipes. The shop offers an impressive lineup of over 20 to 25 rotating flavors—including banana bread crumble, Biscoff, red velvet, and pistachio—alongside unique creations like pudding tacos and pudding-filled cupcakes. Creators celebrate it as a welcoming hidden gem known for its warm service and high-quality treats.
Commenters are overwhelmingly enthusiastic, praising the pudding as delicious and highlighting standout options like the banana bread crumble topping and ube flavor. The owner's friendly and attentive customer service is universally commended, winning over even those who do not typically eat sweets. While sentiment is glowing, occasional discussions touch on pricing and portion sizes.
- Order standout flavors like banana bread crumble, ube, pistachio, and red velvet.
- Try novelty menu items such as pudding tacos, pudding-filled cupcakes, and Oreo cheesecake.
- Expect prices to start just under $11 for a serving, with various sizes available.
- Ask about the rotating daily flavors made from heirloom family recipes.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos