Emmett's on Grove
New York
Emmett's on Grove is a cozy West Village tavern celebrated for its ultra-crispy, Midwestern tavern-style thin-crust pizza, most notably the sweet and spicy 'Hot Girl' topped with pepperoni, jalapeños, and hot honey. Beyond pizza, the menu features Italian-American comfort staples like Caesar salads, pigs in a blanket, and a decadent sea salt-topped chocolate cake. It has also gained traction as an exceptional brunch destination known for famous M&M pancakes, breakfast burritos, and BLTs.
Commenters share high enthusiasm for Emmett's on Grove, specifically praising its cozy, homey tavern atmosphere that feels rare for New York City. Diners frequently highlight the surprising affordability along with strong praise for the food quality, especially discovering the standout pancake-focused brunch menu.
- Order the signature 'Hot Girl' pizza with pepperoni, jalapeño, and hot honey.
- Ask for a side of ranch to pair with the ultra-thin, crispy Peggy'O pizza.
- Visit for brunch to try the famous M&M pancakes, breakfast burrito, or BLT.
- Save room for dessert to enjoy the rich, sea-salted layered chocolate cake.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos