Proper Fish
Bainbridge Island
Located on Bainbridge Island, Proper Fish is widely acclaimed for serving massive, 'bigger than your face' portions of traditional fish and chips featuring an exceptionally crispy batter and flaky fish. In addition to their iconic fish and chips served with signature mushy peas, posts frequently highlight their lobster rolls, loaded fish tacos, and specialty dipping sauces.
Viewer feedback is divided, with devoted fans praising the food as a local staple for over a decade while critics describe it as overly greasy, expensive, or unimpressive. Commenters also warn of potential long wait times and frequently discuss ferry logistics and travel costs to Bainbridge Island.
- Order the traditional fish and chips featuring massive, flaky fried fish.
- Pair your meal with malted vinegar, specialty mayo, or signature mushy peas.
- Consider trying the lobster rolls or loaded fish tacos with shoestring fries.
- Plan ahead for Bainbridge Island ferry schedules and potential long wait times.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos