Keys Fisheries
Marathon
Keys Fisheries in Marathon is a bustling working fishery, marina, and casual open-air restaurant where fishing boats unload fresh catches directly beneath an upstairs tiki bar. It is widely acclaimed for its signature grilled Lobster Reuben packed with meat, alongside dockside stone crab claws, conch fritters, and mahi mahi sandwiches. Visitors consistently highlight the relaxed counter-service atmosphere and scenic harbor views, especially during sunset.
Commenters view Keys Fisheries as an iconic and nostalgic stop along the Florida Keys, frequently praising the fresh food, delicious Key lime pie, and gorgeous sunset vistas. However, there are mixed feelings regarding value, with some patrons noting high prices and shrinking portion sizes, particularly regarding stone crab claws.
- Order the signature grilled Lobster Reuben, widely cited as the must-try dish.
- Head to the upstairs tiki bar for elevated harbor views and to watch boats unload fresh catch.
- Time your visit for dusk to catch the picturesque dockside sunset.
- Save room for a slice of traditional Key lime pie.
- Be prepared for high market prices and potentially smaller portions when ordering stone crab claws.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos