Apollo Bagels
New York
Apollo Bagels is widely celebrated for its hand-rolled, boiled, and baked sourdough bagels characterized by a distinctively chewy interior and an intensely crisp crust. They are primarily served open-faced and finished with high-quality olive oil, cream cheese, and standout toppings like nova lox, capers, dill, and seasoned heirloom tomatoes. Whitefish salad and creative sweet spreads or specials also frequently earn praise.
Commenters generally show strong excitement for Apollo Bagels, though reactions to the texture and price are somewhat polarized. While many consider the bagels top-tier and add the shop to travel itineraries, some local reviewers note the crust can be intensely hard and critique high prices for lox items. A few also debate whether the spot caters heavily to tourists and influencer culture rather than traditional NYC bagel purists.
- Order the open-faced bagel with cream cheese, nova lox, dill, capers, and red onion
- Try the seasoned heirloom tomato or smoked whitefish salad topped with premium olive oil
- Expect an intensely crunchy, sharp outer crust rather than a standard soft bagel texture
- Prepare for premium pricing, especially on smoked fish varieties
- Expect lines and wait times during prime morning and weekend hours
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos