Castaways

Located in the Sandfly neighborhood, Castaways specializes in fresh coastal seafood like Key West rock fish. Visitors can also finish their meal with their homemade key lime pie.

Commenters offered a mixed response, with locals heavily focusing on correcting geographical errors, such as clarifying Castaways is in Sandfly rather than near Tybee Island. Rather than focusing on Castaways itself, many viewers recommended alternative local dining options like Mrs. Wilkes Dining Room, Ukiyo, and Crystal Beer Parlor.