Broad Street Oyster Company
Malibu
Broad Street Oyster Co. in Malibu is renowned for its indulgent coastal seafood, most notably overflowing warm butter lobster rolls and unique creations like the Loburger and caviar-topped hot dogs. A major highlight is their griddled chopped lobster Caesar wrap, which is served with rich dipping dressing exclusively at the Malibu location. Guests also rave about the casual, post-beach outdoor vibe paired with oysters, fries, and frozen piña coladas.
Commenters show massive enthusiasm and intense cravings for the food, often calling it a favorite destination, but significant skepticism surrounds its value. Many viewers complain about high prices and disposable serviceware, accusing social media posts of showcasing oversized 'influencer portions' with far more lobster meat than standard customer orders. Feedback is particularly critical of the lobster Caesar wrap, with patrons reporting heavy lettuce ratios and sparse seafood.
- Order the signature warm butter lobster roll for the most reliable seafood portion.
- Try the griddled chopped lobster Caesar wrap, an exclusive item at the Malibu outpost.
- Sample the smashburger or loburger hybrid if you want a hearty alternative to pure seafood.
- Round out your meal with their underrated french fries and a frozen piña colada.
- Prepare for long lines, high prices, and casual paper-and-aluminum takeout service.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos