S&P Lunch
New York
Occupying the historic former Eisenberg's space in Flatiron, S&P Lunch is a beloved classic diner and luncheonette celebrated for its nostalgic counter seating and traditional Jewish deli fare. Standout menu favorites highlighted by creators include their essential tuna melt, roast turkey sandwich with Swiss and slaw, pastrami, crisp latkes, and old-school fountain drinks like Dr. Brown's cream soda.
Commenters warmly embrace S&P Lunch as a cherished old-school New York institution, frequently reminiscing about its past life as Eisenberg's. Viewer sentiment is overwhelmingly enthusiastic, with particular praise aimed at the classic tuna melt and the thick-cut turkey.
- Sit directly at the lunch counter for the full vintage luncheonette experience.
- Order signature sandwiches like the famous tuna melt (#7) or pastrami (#2).
- Try the thick-cut turkey sandwich served on rye with Swiss, slaw, and Russian dressing.
- Pair your meal with cottage fries, crisp potato latkes, and a Dr. Brown's cream soda.
- Save room for classic desserts like carrot cake or fluffy buttermilk pancakes.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos