Petee's Pie Company
New York
Petee's Pie Company is a dedicated pie shop in the Lower East Side celebrated for handmade pies that highlight natural fruit flavors rather than excessive sweetness. Offerings include slices like blueberry pie with whipped cream, chocolate chess pie, and an apple pecan crumble pie featuring a gooey spiced apple filling. Slices are served in a cozy storefront setting alongside fresh cream-top milk.
Commenters consistently adore Petee's Pie Company, often hailing it as their go-to bakery for classic, premium pies. They rave about flavors like blueberry and guava, praising the balanced recipes that avoid being overly sugary, while also noting the inviting buttery aroma that greets passersby outside.
- Order the blueberry pie topped with fresh whipped cream
- Try the apple pecan crumble pie for a gooey spiced filling
- Pair your dessert with fresh cream-top milk
- Sample non-fruit favorites like the chocolate chess pie
- Look out for crowd-pleasing specialties like the guava pie
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos