DiMaggio's Italian Restaurant
Scottsdale
DiMaggio's in Scottsdale delivers an old-school New York Italian dining atmosphere with scratch-made dishes crafted from family recipes. Reviewers heavily praise showstopping plates like the bone-in veal parmesan, 36-layer lasagna, 'The Don' meatball, and Barolo braised short ribs. Multiple creators also highlight their commitment to quality ingredients, generous portions, house-made mozzarella, and complimentary limoncello.
Viewer opinions are mixed to positive, frequently lauding the welcoming staff, attentive hospitality, and delicious food quality. However, several commenters push back on high prices, specifically calling out expensive items like the $45 chicken parmesan or noting inconsistent execution. Others debate its authenticity compared to other local Italian establishments like Andreoli.
- Must-order dishes include the bone-in veal parmesan, 'The Don' meatball, and 36-layer lasagna
- Expect hefty, sharing-friendly portion sizes
- Look forward to complimentary house-made limoncello after your meal
- Be mindful of steep entree prices, especially for staple poultry dishes
- Dishes are prepared with 100% Italian olive oil and organic ingredients rather than seed oils
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos