Mama's TOO! Pizzeria West Village
New York
Mama's TOO! in the West Village is celebrated as a dual-threat destination renowned for both its artisanal square pizza slices and loaded gourmet sandwiches. Signature pizza offerings feature crispy, caramelized crusts with inventive toppings such as Mexican street corn, poached pear, cacio e pepe, and vodka sauce swirls. Their viral sandwiches, including a Philly cheesesteak with house-made whiz and a crispy chicken alla vodka cutlet with burrata, are served on exceptionally crunchy, house-baked seeded baguettes.
Commenters frequently praise the food's bold visual appeal and flavor, but opinions are sharply divided over premium pricing, with multiple users balking at $10 slices and $22–$25 sandwiches. The house-made bread sparks lively debate, with some loving the deep crunch while others find it far too hard to chew comfortably. Additionally, purists question heavily loaded options like the elote slice, arguing it resembles overloaded flatbread more than traditional pizza.
- Try standout square slices like the Mexican Corn (elote), Poached Pear, and Angry Nonna.
- Split viral sandwiches like the Chicken Alla Vodka or Philly Cheesesteak, which are large enough for two.
- Expect an extremely hard and crunchy texture on the house-made seeded baguettes.
- Anticipate premium prices, with specialty sandwiches reaching $25 and individual slices up to $10.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos