Astoria Seafood
Long Island City
Astoria Seafood is a bustling Queens market-and-restaurant hybrid where diners select fresh raw fish directly from ice displays to be weighed and grilled or fried to order with Greek seasonings. The venue features an energetic and casual atmosphere with communal and outdoor seating, along with a popular bring-your-own-drinks policy. Standout menu offerings highlighted include fried whole red snapper in garlic butter, seasoned grilled lobster tail, soft-shell crab, giant prawns, and calamari.
Commenters consistently praise the fresh, flavorful seafood portions and warm Greek hospitality, with many locals attempting to gatekeep the beloved institution. However, frequent criticisms focus on exceptionally long wait times, heavy crowds, and occasional order errors. Several patrons also express frustration over a perceived lack of pricing transparency at the counter and the contrast of high-end seafood served with plastic utensils.
- Select raw fish and shellfish directly from the ice trays to be grilled or fried to order.
- Try customer favorites such as fried whole red snapper, grilled lobster tail, and soft-shell crab.
- Take advantage of the venue's BYOB policy for drinks.
- Inquire about per-pound prices at the counter before weighing to avoid billing surprises.
- Expect long lines and communal seating during peak dining hours.
- Be prepared for a very casual setting that utilizes plastic plates and utensils.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos