Jacob's Pickles
New York
Jacob's Pickles is a famously busy, iconic NYC Southern-style comfort food destination celebrated for its extensive pickle selection and massive portion sizes. Standout signature menu items include fried chicken biscuit sandwiches, buffalo chicken mac and cheese, fried pickles, and a viral chicken Caesar wrap made with biscuit croutons. It is also heavily praised for its indulgent desserts, particularly the warm red velvet bread pudding topped with vanilla ice cream and the 24-layer chocolate cake.
Commenters generally express high excitement and strong brand loyalty, praising the visually appealing, indulgent food and calling out items like the burger, mac and cheese, and wraps as favorites. However, some viewers express skepticism, with specific critiques pointing toward a perceived decline in overall quality alongside rising prices and reduced portion sizes. Others frequently inquire about menu availability, location corrections, and Restaurant Week logistics.
- Order top signature dishes like the hot chicken biscuits, buffalo chicken mac and cheese, and fried pickles.
- Try the viral $12-$13 chicken Caesar wrap featuring unique southern biscuit croutons, available at the Moynihan Train Hall location.
- Save room for the popular warm red velvet bread pudding topped with cold vanilla ice cream.
- Look out for $30 lunch and $45 dinner set menus during NYC Restaurant Week.
- Keep in mind that recent visitors note potential crowds, higher prices, and shifting portion sizes.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos