Millport Dairy
New York
Millport Dairy is a small Amish storefront on the Upper West Side stocked directly by a farmer from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. The shop supplies New Yorkers with unprocessed organic produce, farm-fresh eggs, meats, cheeses, and raw milk. Shoppers can also find an assortment of homemade baked goods, whoopie pies, breads, pickled vegetables, and unique jams.
Commenters generally appreciate the farm-fresh offerings, enthusiastically praising items like the applesauce, homemade granola, rich eggs, and zucchini baked goods, along with the friendly owner. However, sentiment is sharply divided over the raw milk, with critics flagging health concerns and its steep $28-per-gallon price tag.
- Pick up homemade baked goods like whoopie pies and zucchini treats
- Try the highly recommended applesauce and house-made granola
- Look for farm-fresh poultry, rich eggs, and Lancaster cheeses
- Be mindful of the $28-per-gallon price tag and health debates around raw milk
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos