Frosty's cake + ice cream

Frosty's is a Lakewood, Ohio sweet shop known for its wide selection of baked goods, including cupcakes, cookies, brownies, and cake by the slice. A standout favorite is their oatmeal cream pie, which creators praise as delicious enough to buy weekly.

Commenters share an overwhelmingly enthusiastic love for the bakery's treats, specifically spotlighting the s'mores cookie and their custom wedding cakes. The main caveats mentioned are inquiries regarding vegan options and awareness of their limited, weekend-only operating hours.