Casey Rubber Stamps
New York
Casey Rubber Stamps is celebrated as New York City's last traditional rubber stamp shop, packing over 15,000 vintage and handcrafted designs floor-to-ceiling in a cozy East Village space. Operating for nearly five decades, the workshop uses vintage machinery to hand-cut natural rubber mounted onto maple wood blocks, offering everything from NYC-themed motifs to fully custom creations. Browsing the compact, time-capsule shop is widely described as a charming, therapeutic experience, often complemented by the presence of Ratty, the resident shop cat.
Commenters share strong enthusiasm and nostalgia for the shop, frequently highlighting positive experiences with custom orders and praising the stamp quality. Many fondly mention the resident cat and inquire about online ordering capabilities for out-of-towners. While sentiment is overwhelmingly supportive, a couple of commenters noted an uncomfortable atmosphere during their visit or voiced concern over a specific catalog design.
- Bring in personal artwork or logos to have a custom stamp hand-crafted on-site.
- Arrive during off-peak times since the narrow, compact shop gets crowded easily.
- Say hello to Ratty, the beloved resident shop cat.
- Check out the signature NYC-themed designs, including detailed manhole covers and city skylines.
- Allow extra time to thoroughly browse through catalogs containing over 15,000 vintage designs.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos