Medium Rare
New York
Medium Rare is widely celebrated for its straightforward $35 three-course prix-fixe meal that begins with rustic bread and a mixed green salad. The highlight of the meal is culotte steak and fresh-cut crispy fries smothered in their signature secret sauce, which uniquely includes a built-in second warm serving. Creators praise the incredible value, attentive service, and casual yet lively dining atmosphere.
Commenter sentiment is divided between those who consider it an unbeatable value for casual date nights and those critical of the food quality. While many praise the famous secret sauce and desserts like carrot cake, others complain about tough steak, overly salty fries, and question whether the doneness matches expectations. Despite mixed takes on portion sizes and meat tenderness, it remains a popular spot across its multiple cities.
- Opt for the $35 prix-fixe menu to get rustic bread, salad, and steak frites.
- Pace yourself during dinner to leave room for the automatic second serving of hot steak and fries.
- Be explicit about your preferred meat doneness when placing your order.
- Consider trying the carrot cake to finish off your meal.
- Keep in mind that the house sauce and fries can lean salty for some palates.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos