Penny

Located in the East Village, Penny earned acclaim as the #3 new restaurant in NYC for 2024 according to Beli users. The standout highlight is its ornate sesame-topped pull-apart brioche loaf, which is served alongside a generous scoop of sea salt-flecked butter.

Commenters expressed excitement over the bread and butter feature while frequently tagging friends to plan visits. Many users also engaged by comparing it to other standout city spots and pitching their own favorite hidden gems that they felt deserved recognition.