Pop’s Pizza FlatIron

Located steps from Madison Square Park, Pop’s Pizza FlatIron is a compact parlor serving some of the thinnest slices in the area. The crust is light and delicate with a satisfying chew, finished with a distinctively sharp and nutty dusting of parmesan cheese.

Commenters appreciated highlighting slice shops that fly under the radar instead of focusing strictly on viral spots. Many engaged with the feature by sharing their own neighborhood favorites and alternative recommendations across Manhattan.