The Pastry Box
New York
Founded by Chef Tiara Bennett, The Pastry Box is a Black-owned East Village bakery best known for its massive quarter-pound chocolate chip cookies that are flattened mid-bake to achieve a thin, crispy edge with an exceptionally dense and chewy center. Alongside their signature salt-dusted cookies, the bakery receives acclaim for its artisan coiled cinnamon buns topped with thick icing, moist carrot cake, and classic black and white cookies.
Commenters are overwhelmingly enthusiastic about the bakery, frequently celebrating it as home to some of the absolute best cookies in New York City. Followers love the finishing touch of flaky sea salt and warmly express support for owner Tiara Bennett's inspiring success.
- Order the signature quarter-pound chocolate chip cookie finished with Maldon sea salt.
- Try the tall, coiled artisan cinnamon bun with thick white icing.
- Sample the moist carrot cake topped with light whipped cream cheese frosting.
- Check out seasonal treats like the pumpkin loaf and black and white cookies.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos