Martiny’s

Housed inside a historic 1800s carriage house formerly owned by sculptor Philip Martiny, this Gramercy bar was co-founded by Takuma Watanabe. It is celebrated for its precise Japanese cocktail craftsmanship, elegant presentation, and signature drinks like the Grand Martiny's.

Commenters largely overlooked Martiny's directly, choosing instead to debate and recommend alternative iconic NYC bars such as Amor y Amargo and Bemelmans Bar. The broader feedback mostly revolved around competing neighborhood favorites without specific consensus on Martiny's itself.