Salem Cross Inn
West Brookfield
Salem Cross Inn is an authentic 18th-century tavern in West Brookfield, Massachusetts, celebrated for its seasonal colonial Fireplace Feasts. Guests enjoy open-hearth cooking with prime rib roasted over wild cherry logs on an antique roasting jack, cauldron fish chowder, mulled cider heated with hot irons, and homemade deep-dish apple pie. The immersive historic experience also features horse-drawn wagon or sleigh rides on the property grounds.
Commenters share overwhelming enthusiasm for the dining experience, frequently recommending the Fireplace Feasts, murder mystery events, and its setting as a wedding venue. However, several diners warn about the steep $89 ticket price and the difficulty of securing reservations. A few isolated remarks also express frustration with management or customer service regarding bookings.
- Book Fireplace Feast tickets well in advance due to high demand
- Expect to spend around $89 per ticket for special feast events
- Don't miss the open-hearth roasted prime rib and cauldron fish chowder
- Try the unique cider mulled with glowing hot fireplace irons
- Look out for special seasonal events like murder mystery dinners
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos