Eddie's Sweet Shop

Operating since 1925, Eddie's Sweet Shop is New York City's oldest ice cream parlor, featuring historic marble counters and vintage equipment. Located in Forest Hills, the parlor makes all 18 ice cream flavors, fountain sodas, syrups, and whipped cream in-house from original recipes, specializing in classic sundaes loaded with toppings.

While commenters express deep nostalgia and praise for the classic old-school atmosphere and tasty ice cream, many note significant downsides. Visitors frequently point out high prices, strict cash-only policies, and limited operating days, with some leaving sharp criticism regarding poor customer service.