Nancy's

Nancy's is a walk-up ice cream and takeout shack in New Buffalo, situated near the harbor and downtown across from Postboy. The spot is best known for its thick strawberry milkshakes, classic ice cream scoops, shakes, and dog-friendly pup cups.

Viewer sentiment is broadly enthusiastic about the destination recommendations, with many people asking about pet-friendliness and beach getaway logistics. A local confirmed the creator selected top spots, though some viewers expressed minor skepticism regarding travel times.