Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street

Goodfellas Pizzeria is a popular downtown Lexington staple celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza served by the slice. It is especially noted for late-night dining, featuring signature giant seasoned breadsticks with dipping sauce and local fountain Ale-8 soda.

Viewer sentiment is broadly positive, with many commenters validating the pizzeria as a legitimate local favorite and sharing strong cravings for a visit. The lunch specials receive specific praise, though a few commenters noted mixed feelings compared to other local establishments.