Hamburger America
New York
Hamburger America is widely praised by creators as one of New York City's top destinations for historic American diner-style burgers. The standout highlight is burger scholar George Motz's classic double fried onion burger. Media lists frequently recommend it as an essential stop for classic burgers and cheap eats in the city.
Audience comments reveal notable pushback and mixed reviews, with critics arguing the venue is overhyped compared to other smashburger staples. Viewers also debate whether it truly counts as a 'cheap eat,' often expressing frustration over high burger prices across trending NYC food spots. Sentiment trends lean skeptical, with commenters frequently comparing it critically against local neighborhood favorites.
- Order the signature double fried onion burger curated by George Motz.
- Expect diner-style smashburgers rather than thick pub patties.
- Be mindful of costs, as commenters note prices may exceed typical 'cheap eat' expectations.
- Visit with tempered expectations if comparing against other popular NYC smashburger spots.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos