Madison Avenue Pizza

Madison Avenue Pizza is known for its massive 32-inch scratch-made pizzas, hearty chicken subs, and shaved ribeye cheesesteaks. Reviewers highly praise the cheesesteak, which is served on a daily fresh-baked 10-inch Italian seeded roll with grilled onions, mushrooms, and cheese.

Commenters focused heavily on the creator's addition of mayonnaise to the cheesesteak, passionately arguing that it ruins the sandwich's authenticity and invalidates the review. Despite the controversy, Madison Avenue Pizza celebrated the high review score, while some viewers debated alternative local cheesesteak spots.