Makars Mash Bar
Edinburgh
Makars Mash Bar is celebrated by creators for hearty traditional Scottish comfort food centered around artisanal mashed potato pairings and slow-cooked meats. Frequent highlights include signature dishes like the tender lamb shank, haggis, neeps, and tatties, along with classic desserts like sticky toffee pudding and Cranachan. While widely praised as a fairly priced independent gem near the Royal Mile, a minority of reviewers caution that excessive hype can lead to unrealistic expectations for what is essentially homely, rustic fare.
Commenters frequently praise Makars Mash Bar for its hearty portion sizes, great value, and standout savory dishes like the beef and haggis mash. While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive about the food quality, an occasional commenter warns that the spot feels slightly overhyped. Discussion also extends to Edinburgh trip planning, where visitors emphasize finding authentic, satisfying meals off the tourist-heavy path.
- Must-try dishes include the slow-cooked lamb shank and traditional haggis, neeps, and tatties.
- Pair your meal with their specialty gourmet mashed potatoes and rich house gravies.
- Save room for classic Scottish desserts such as Cranachan and sticky toffee pudding.
- Approach the restaurant expecting comforting, home-style cooking rather than upscale fine dining to avoid hype disappointment.
- Conveniently located near the Royal Mile, offering generous portions and independent value.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos