Lexington Candy Shop
New York
Lexington Candy Shop is a historic century-old Upper East Side luncheonette celebrated as one of the last vintage soda fountains mixing Coca-Cola completely by hand using original syrup and seltzer water. Alongside classic ice cream floats topped with Bassetts ice cream and traditional New York egg creams, the diner preserves a nostalgic 1920s to 1940s atmosphere while serving staple comfort fare like burgers, sliders, and pancakes.
Viewer sentiments are strongly polarized, balancing retro nostalgia and excitement against sharp critiques of high prices, with some reporting the hand-mixed Coke costs nearly $12. Multiple patrons complain that the drinks taste flat, watery, or overhyped, and some note curt service and underwhelming diner food, while others still cherish the authentic old-school charm.
- Order the signature hand-mixed Coca-Cola float topped with Bassetts vanilla ice cream.
- Try traditional New York soda fountain staples like authentic egg creams.
- Be prepared for high prices on vintage specialty drinks, running upwards of $12.
- Stick to fountain novelties, as standard food items like French toast get mixed reviews.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos