Sugar Hill Creamery
New York
Sugar Hill Creamery is a family- and Black-owned artisanal ice cream shop in Harlem crafting small-batch scoops inspired by Caribbean, Midwestern, and local Harlem culture. Creators highlight inventive, seasonal offerings such as peach cobbler, graham cracker blueberry jam, and Lenten Habichuelas con Dulce, alongside indulgent treats like carrot cake ice cream cake and torched marshmallow hot chocolate.
Commenters are overwhelmingly enthusiastic, often declaring it the best ice cream in New York City with exceptionally unique flavors. Visitors praise the welcoming staff and note favorites like the peach cobbler scoop, hot cocoa, and non-dairy options, while expressing strong pride in supporting a Black woman-owned Harlem staple.
- Order standout seasonal scoops like peach cobbler, graham cracker blueberry jam, or Habichuelas con Dulce during Lent.
- Try the seasonal hot chocolate topped with a torched marshmallow.
- Explore their selection of non-dairy flavors and seasonal ice cream cakes like carrot cake.
- Visit the Harlem flagship location to experience the warm, family-owned neighborhood atmosphere.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos