Taqueria by El Prieto NYC
New York
Taqueria by El Prieto brings Tijuana and San Diego-style Mexican street food to NYC, celebrated for its massive portions and extensive self-serve salsa bar. Standout menu items include marinated al pastor, cheese-crusted mulitas, loaded carne asada fries, and all-day breakfast burritos served with handmade tortillas. Guests also consistently highlight their refreshing housemade aguas frescas, particularly cucumber lime and horchata.
Audience reactions are mixed, with many expressing excitement and praising the authentic, visual presentation of the dishes. However, commenters frequently debate value, criticizing steep NYC taco prices and questioning whether the flavor—especially the chicken and seasoning—truly matches the creator hype.
- Try the signature cheese-crusted mulitas or Vampiro al Pastor.
- Order the massive loaded carne asada fries or surf and turf burritos for sharing.
- Take advantage of the extensive self-serve salsa bar to customize your spice level.
- Pair rich dishes with fresh housemade aguas frescas like cucumber lime or horchata.
- Stop in for their hearty all-day breakfast burritos packed with eggs, chorizo, and potatoes.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos