Secret Pizza
Los Angeles
Secret Pizza has evolved from a home-based operation into a beloved El Sereno brick-and-mortar hailed as one of Los Angeles' best traditional New York-style pizza spots. Reviewers celebrate its outstanding dough texture, high-quality ingredients, and friendly service, with particular acclaim for its Sicilian cheese slice and signature unique ranch dressing. It holds a reputation as a reliable household go-to that brings the pride of New Jersey pizza craft to the West Coast.
Audience reception leans noticeably critical regarding value, with commenters pushing back against boutique pizza price tags and calling the spot overpriced and mediocre. Viewer discussions frequently compare it unfavorably against other prominent Los Angeles pizzerias, questioning its top-tier rankings.
- Order the Sicilian cheese slice, highlighted as an absolute standout.
- Try their unique house ranch dressing alongside your slices.
- Prepare for higher boutique pizza prices that spark mixed reactions among locals.
- Pick up a pie for an easy, high-quality movie night meal.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos