Liberty Bagels Wall Street
New York
Liberty Bagels is renowned across social media as the home of the iconic, vibrant rainbow bagel, offering an impressive lineup of 28 bagel varieties including sourdough and sweet options. The shop is equally famous for its massive spread selection, boasting 28 homemade cream cheeses that range from sweet birthday cake and strawberry to savory and tofu-based alternatives. Visitors consistently highlight their heavily loaded breakfast sandwiches and colorful, eye-catching pairings.
Audience reactions are enthusiastic yet polarized, with many fans labeling it an essential NYC staple and raving about standout picks like the French toast bagel and Oreo cream cheese. While numerous out-of-state commenters beg for nationwide shipping, local skeptics argue the shop leans touristy and overhyped, occasionally faulting the bagels for being ordinary or excessively smothered in cream cheese.
- Order the iconic rainbow bagel paired with birthday cake or strawberry cream cheese
- Sample fan-favorite combos like the French toast bagel with Oreo cream cheese
- Ask for lighter cream cheese if you dislike overly thick spreads
- Choose sourdough or traditional savory bagels if you want an authentic New York deli profile
- Expect a busy, tourist-friendly crowd drawn by the viral aesthetic
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos