Strickland's Ice Cream, Costa Mesa CA

Strickland's Ice Cream in Costa Mesa is celebrated for its freshly made frozen custard and soft serve, which are known for their exceptionally rich, creamy, and stretchy texture. Alongside staples like rich egg-based chocolate and smooth vanilla, the shop features unique rotating daily flavors via a monthly calendar, with Peanut Butter Oreo and milkshakes being major highlights.

Commenters express deep nostalgia and love for the brand, frequently reminiscing about its past Irvine location and praising the friendly owner. Peanut Butter Oreo remains a clear crowd favorite, though a few dissenters feel the current spot is mid or lacks the desired thickness.