Sugar Hill Creamery
New York
Sugar Hill Creamery's East Harlem location on Lexington Avenue offers a rotating selection of handcrafted, house-made ice cream scoops and frozen treats. The shop is particularly recognized for unique seasonal specialties, such as Habichuelas con Dulce made with sweet bean paste and raisin gelée, alongside seasonal carrot cake desserts. Both limited-run creative batches and year-round classic flavors define their menu.
Commenters share enthusiastic praise and affection for the shop, frequently expressing strong excitement to try featured flavors. Specific items like Butter Pecan Butter Cake and Tell It to the Block generate significant buzz, with many visitors eager to return for both new innovations and reliable classics. Overall, community feedback is thoroughly positive and warm.
- Try distinctive seasonal scoops like Habichuelas con Dulce with raisin gelée
- Sample crowd-pleasing favorites including Butter Pecan Butter Cake and Tell It to the Block
- Stop by this Lexington Avenue shop to pick up their seasonal carrot cake dessert
- Check the rotating menu regularly for new house-made flavors and frozen treats
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos