Pugsley Pizza

Pugsley Pizza is a legendary late-night Bronx staple that has become a beloved fixture among college students. The spot serves up classic New York slices, pepperoni, and margherita pizzas. A signature highlight of the experience is their house-made fiery pepper oil available to elevate each slice.

Commenters adore this mom-and-pop gem, frequently calling it one of the Bronx's best-kept secrets. Beyond the delicious pizza and must-try garlic knots, guests consistently highlight the kind and welcoming nature of the owners. Enthusiasts also recommend dropping by for late-night offerings like the buffalo chicken slice.