Prince Street Pizza
Costa Mesa
Prince Street Pizza brings its famous New York-style thick, crunchy Sicilian square slices loaded with crispy pepperoni cups to Costa Mesa. Creators consistently highlight signature pies like the Spicy Spring and the Naughty Pie, topped with spicy vodka sauce, ricotta, and hot honey, which regularly wins over even non-pizza fans. While praised for bold flavors and standout sides like smoked mozzarella sticks, occasional reviews note that crust texture can vary.
Viewer reception is polarized, with enthusiastic fans praising the mouthwatering visual appeal and signature menu items. However, several commenters argue the food is overrated and overpriced, raising occasional complaints about inconsistent quality, hygiene, and customer service.
- Try signature square slices like the Naughty Pie (vodka sauce, ricotta, hot honey) and the Spicy Spring.
- Expect thick, crunchy Sicilian-style crusts loaded with cupping pepperoni.
- Check out side items including smoked mozzarella sticks and arancini.
- Be prepared for higher slice prices compared to standard local pizza joints.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos