Gooey on The Inside (Chrystie Street)
New York
Gooey on The Inside is a Black-owned NYC bakery founded by Kafi, famed for its decadent, oversized cookies featuring a crisp crust and a molten, molten center. The shop offers inventive desserts like scoopable cookie dough jars, injected fillings such as Nutella or cream, and cookie dough topped with soft-serve ice cream. Standout flavor creations include their toasted s'mores cookie and unique 'toast and jam' specialty drops.
Commenters are overwhelmingly enthusiastic about the rich, gooey textures and innovative flavor concepts like jam-on-toast. While out-of-town fans frequently plead for nationwide shipping and international expansion, some local patrons raise minor concerns about premium pricing and store hours.
- Order the signature toasted s'mores or unique toast and jam cookies.
- Try warm scoopable cookie dough topped with soft-serve and Nutella drizzle.
- Ask for optional injected fillings like Nutella or cream for extra decadence.
- Keep an eye out for their non-alcoholic cookie happy hour for evening deals.
- Consider nationwide shipping if you want to skip the line or send treats to friends.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos