Nicky's Undefeated (Cheesesteaks & Hoagies)
Tucker
Located in Tucker, Georgia, Nicky's Undefeated specializes in authentic Philly cheesesteaks, cutlet sandwiches, hoagies, and sides. Their signature cheesesteaks feature sliced ribeye and Cooper Sharp cheese served on seeded hoagie rolls or bread imported directly from Liscio's Bakery. The menu also offers gluten-free bread options alongside a variety of salads, pretzels, and side dishes.
Customer opinions are strongly divided, with some calling it the best cheesesteak in Atlanta while others label it overpriced and disappointing. While many commenters praise the hoagies, cheesesteaks, and egg rolls, others complain about inconsistent quality, unheated buns, and poor customer service. Additional frustration stems from an inability to place phone orders for pickup, alongside criticism of the pizza and chicken parm.
- Order classic Philly cheesesteaks made with sliced ribeye and Cooper Sharp cheese.
- Try popular sides like egg rolls and hoagies.
- Take advantage of gluten-free bread options if needed.
- Skip the pizza and chicken parm sandwich according to customer feedback.
- Note that phone orders for pickup are not accepted.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos