Polly's NYC
New York
Polly's is an underground 1920s-style speakeasy nestled beneath Tanner Smith's in Midtown Manhattan, accessed via unmarked stairs and a hidden leather door. The venue is celebrated for its vintage ambiance, featuring tufted red seating, gallery walls, live jazz, and nightly burlesque or live singers until 9 PM. A major signature highlight is their specialty craft cocktails uniquely served in vintage teapots and decorative teacups.
Commenters react with high enthusiasm for the cool speakeasy atmosphere and especially adore the cute vintage teacups. Many viewers share positive experiences using the venue for celebrations like birthdays and date nights. Frequent practical discussions revolve around booking reservations, entry logistics, and age requirements.
- Catch live singers and jazz performances nightly before 9 PM.
- Order the signature cocktails served in decorative teapots and vintage teacups.
- Look for the hidden entrance down unmarked stairs and behind a leather door under Tanner Smith's.
- Check reservation requirements in advance, especially for date nights or birthday celebrations.
- Explore the dinner menu, which features clearly marked vegan options.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos