Witchery by the Castle
Edinburgh
Located right beside Edinburgh Castle on the Royal Mile, The Witchery by the Castle is an opulent, historic dining venue and boutique hotel renowned for its dramatic candlelight and ornate gothic aesthetic. Posts highlight atmospheric spaces like the Secret Garden and decadent Scottish dishes, including scallops, duck, beef tartare, and Scotch Côte de Bœuf with truffle mash. The venue is also celebrated for lavish seasonal courtyard decor and a vintage street photographer stationed just outside.
Audience reactions are sharply divided between romantic awe and frustration over value. Many praise the unforgettable gothic atmosphere, attentive staff, and memorable meals, deeming it a dream spot for special occasions. However, a significant portion of commenters warn that the restaurant is overpriced and overrated, cautioning that the food and service can be mediocre relative to the steep prices.
- Reserve tables several months in advance to secure a spot
- Opt for the two-course lunch menu for a more economical dining option
- Order signature menu items like Scotch Côte de Bœuf, duck, or fresh scallops
- Solo diners can try walking in for lunch without a booking
- Stop by the vintage newspaper street photographer stationed outside the entrance
- Visit during autumn to see elaborate seasonal and pumpkin courtyard displays
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos