John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Housed inside an abandoned church, John's Pizzeria of Times Square impresses with its grand stained-glass ceiling and arched windows. The massive pizzeria operates four 800-degree coal-fired brick ovens that bake signature thin-crust pizzas and mozzarella-stuffed garlic rolls.

Commenters widely praise the fantastic pizza and stunning church architecture, often calling it a must-visit staple during NYC trips. However, some diners noted high noise levels, mixed reactions to the pizza flavor, and unexpected credit card surcharges.