Prince Street Pizza
New York
Prince Street Pizza is an iconic Nolita slice shop celebrated for its thick, crispy Sicilian-style square slices piled high with spicy cupping pepperoni. Creators consistently spotlight signature items like the legendary Spicy Spring slice with diavolo sauce and the decadent Naughty Pie, which features spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey. While praised for its saucy, crispy-bottomed crust, some note that asking for an extra-crispy reheat ensures the perfect crunch.
Commenters reflect high enthusiasm, often describing the pizza visuals as mouthwatering and labeling the pizzeria as a top-tier NYC staple. Audiences frequently express intense cravings and celebrate expansions outside New York, though some viewers debate whether it belongs on generic influencer lists compared to other classic slice shops.
- Order the signature Spicy Spring slice with crispy pepperoni cups and spicy marinara
- Try the Naughty Pie for spicy vodka sauce, ricotta, pepperoni, and hot honey
- Request your square slice extra crispy if you prefer a deeper crunch on the bottom
- Grab dipping sauces like hot honey or ranch to elevate the thick crust edges
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos