Slice of New York Pizza
Seal Beach
Slice of New York Pizza is celebrated for its authentic New York-style pies and massive, made-to-order calzones, featuring house-made dough and sauce. Standout menu items include the 'Sweet & Spicy Pie' with chorizo and the 'OG Classic' topped with ricotta and hot honey. Whether visiting the Seal Beach location with its classic sports memorabilia vibe or the Long Beach street vendor setup, customers enjoy high-quality ingredients and a traditional pizzeria experience.
Customer opinions on A Slice of New York Pizza are deeply divided, with some praising the pizza and wings as 'fire' while others report significant quality concerns. Despite reports of inconsistency, many patrons view it as a hidden gem and highly recommend the visually appealing food and hot lemon pepper wings.
- Order the 'Sweet & Spicy Pie' with chorizo or the 'OG Classic' with ricotta and hot honey.
- Try the hot lemon pepper wings, which are highly recommended by frequent patrons.
- Visit the Seal Beach location if you prefer a classic sports memorabilia ambiance.
- Be prepared for potential inconsistency in food quality despite the high-quality ingredients.
- Look for the Long Beach street vendor setup for a more casual, traditional experience.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos