ButterMilks Bakery
Hillsboro
ButterMilks Bakery in Hillsboro, Ohio, specializes in oversized, indulgent desserts headlined by massive 5-pound specialty cheesecakes served by the slice. In addition to rotating cheesecake flavors like caramel apple, peach, and fluffernutter, they offer deluxe stuffed cookies, oversized brownies, whoopie pies, and mini bundt cakes. Guests can also enjoy specialty drinks, including iced coffees and gelato.
Commenters are overwhelmingly enthusiastic, with many claiming the bakery is worth planning multi-hour road trips to experience. The audience heavily praises the generous portions and budget-friendly $6 price tag for cheesecake slices, alongside popular favorites like cookies and strawberry cream.
- Try the massive 5-pound specialty cheesecakes available by the slice in rotating flavors.
- Cheesecake slices are noted as a great value at just $6 each.
- Sample other popular baked goods like deluxe stuffed cookies, whoopie pies, and oversized brownies.
- Pair your treats with specialty drinks like iced coffee or gelato.
Summaries are created based on reviews, notes, and social media posts.
Photos