Amityville recommendations: where to eat, drink and go in Amityville, NY
11 places in Amityville, NY that creators on TikTok, Instagram and YouTube have posted about. Each one comes with what people say about it.
Bayview Kitchen
Enjoy flavorful Caribbean classics in a warm, welcoming setting featuring a creative salmon and grits twist.
Fortunate Hand Coffee House
Amityville's modern coffee destination offers high-quality iced brews within a unique hand-themed aesthetic that sparks local debate.
Brownstones Coffee Amityville
Breakfast spot featuring fantastic French toast and an expansive menu, though considered overrated by vocal locals.
Nyam Sum Jamaican Cuisine
Long Island eatery offering fall-off-the-bone oxtail, savory homemade patties, and house-crafted fruit juices for an authentic Caribbean taste.
Amity Play Cove
A charming, community-focused indoor play center featuring aesthetic pretend play setups and active climbing structures designed specifically for young kids.
The Cone Depot
Grab indulgent comfort-food waffle cones inside an unassuming gas station setting, paired with sweet dipped treats next door.
Amityville Apothecary
A charming two-floor metaphysical shop offering crystals and spell supplies alongside an adjoining bookstore parlour featuring aura photography and readings.
New York Beanery
Enjoy a whimsical brunch featuring bear-shaped coffee and creative lattes in a playful, social-media-ready atmosphere.
112 Ocean Ave
Famous as an iconic haunted location, this spot attracts an enthusiastic paranormal community eager to discuss supernatural lore.
Hidden Blooms Flower Farm
Enjoy a charming pesticide-free u-pick flower experience in labeled field rows alongside fresh strawberries and pre-made bouquets.
Anchor Coffee
Sip a large iced coffee at this Amityville staple that serves as a local rotation favorite for Long Island residents.
